Collecting Conan: Are the Del Reys Enough?
Saturday, July 29, 2006
posted by Rob Roehm

With the appearance of the Del Rey Conan series, it’s never been easier for Howard fans to collect unadulterated tales of everyone’s favorite Cimmerian. Before these illustrated volumes showed up, it was a nightmare; collectors had to find the Karl Edward Wagner edited Berkley series which, unfortunately, was never completed; then a whole string of other publications, many, like Cromlech #3, very hard to find. We had to settle for the “deCampenated” version of “The Black Stranger” until 1987, when it was finally published without editorial interference in Echoes of Valor (thanks again, Mr. Wagner).

Today’s collector thinks it’s a snap: all they’ve got to do, they think, is pick up The Coming of Conan the Cimmerian, The Bloody Crown of Conan, and The Conquering Sword of Conan and they’ve got it all — all the stories, all the fragments, all the synopses, the novel, the essay, the poem, and some maps. Well, I guess if you’re happy with most of the Conan canon, these books will probably do. But, for the hardcore Howard-head, there’s still a few related items that need to be had before we can call it “complete.”
Seventeen Conan yarns were sold to Weird Tales during Howard’s lifetime, and all of those stories have been printed and reprinted, with varying degrees of editorial “assistance,” since Gnome Press issued its first Conan book back in 1950: The Hour of the Dragon, inexplicably re-titled Conan the Conqueror. All seventeen of these tales appear in the Del Rey series; some are even accompanied by drafts and/or synopses. It can be quite interesting to see what changes Howard made between a draft and the published version. Besides these seventeen, Howard completed four others: “The Black Stranger,” “The Frost-Giant’s Daughter,” “The God in the Bowl,” and “The Vale of Lost Women”; he started five others, which come to us mostly as “Untitled Fragment” in the Del Rey series, but which are probably better known by the titles deCamp gave them: in the order in which they appear in the Del Rey series, “The Hall of the Dead,” “The Hand of Nergal,” “The Snout in the Dark” (all from The Coming of Conan), “The Drums of Tombulku” (in The Bloody Crown of Conan), and “Wolves Beyond the Border” (from The Conquering Sword of Conan). And, of course, no Conan collection would be complete without the poem that started it all, “Cimmeria,” and the essay that explains it all, “The Hyborian Age.” All these items are in the Del Rey series.
So what’s missing? Well, our first concern is “The Frost-Giant’s Daughter.” Most fans already know that Howard rewrote it, changing Conan to Amra, and submitted it to The Fantasy Fan, where it was published in 1934 as “Gods of the North.” This version of the story is available in Dennis McHaney’s Robert E. Howard’s Strange Tales. But that’s not the end of it. Before either of these tales were written, Howard completed an early draft that has only been published once, in The Dark Man #1. I’m not sure why this wasn’t included in the Del Rey series, and who knows if any other story drafts were omitted.

Next up is “The Black Stranger.” Not even available until 1987, it is now one of the most reprinted of the Conan tales. Not only is it in The Conquering Sword of Conan, it’s also in the Bison Book The Black Stranger and Other American Tales; it was even published as a facsimile copy of Howard’s typescript by the fine folks at Wandering Star; the story is certainly accessible. Not true of Howard’s rewrite. When the story failed to sell, like the above-mentioned “Frost-Giant’s Daughter,” Howard rewrote it, changing it into a pirate yarn aimed at the action/adventure markets. The rewrite didn’t help it, though, and “Swords of the Red Brotherhood” remained unpublished as well, until 1976′s Black Vulmea’s Vengeance. This collection is pretty easy easy to find from the usual used book sellers.

The last item is a technicality. The first official Conan story is “The Phoenix on the Sword,” published in Weird Tales for December 1932, but six months before that, in the June ’32 issue of Strange Tales, a Crom-cursing character called Conan appeared in “The People of the Dark.” With a physical description that’s more like the Cimmerian than not, the only real difference between these two Conans is the times in which they lived. “The People of the Dark” can be found in the above-mentioned McHaney book, as well as Wildside Press’s People of the Dark, the third volume in the Weird Works of Robert E. Howard series. Now you’ve got it all — unless I missed something . . .










