So far 2009 has been a lousy year for fantasy fans who like the feel of good old-fashioned print publications in their hands. Right here on this Web site, we’ve lost the award-winning Robert E. Howard journal The Cimmerian. Elsewhere, long-running fantasy fiction and reviews magazine Realms of Fantasy is closing up shop, ending its 15-year run with the April 2009 issue. And, to top off the bad news, The Year’s Best Fantasy and Horror, a well-regarded “best-of” anthology that spanned 21 years, has also been discontinued.
I’m not about to indulge in hyperbole and declare that print is dead, but there’s no doubt that the void left by these losses feels like, to quote J.R.R. Tolkien scholar Tom Shippey, “another piece of Mordor.”
On some level I feel like a hypocrite for mourning the loss of these publications since I’m not a subscriber or regular buyer. Now, in my defense I wasn’t even aware of The Cimmerian until I came across it after starting my blog, The Silver Key, back in September of 2007, and found it only after some fortuitous Googling.
As for the other two publications, Realms of Fantasy was a bit too “high fantasy” for my tastes, too much folklore and winged fairies and not enough shield walls and treasure plundering heroes, though I have purchased a few issues of the magazine from newsstands. As for The Year’s Best Fantasy and Horror, I’ve always found anthologies to be largely hit-and-miss, and this series to be no exception. I do own a few copies, but these were purchased second-hand from used bookstores.
However, as a fantasy fan and old-fashioned lover of paper (as my three groaning bookshelves, and my disapproving wife, can attest) I find it very sad to see these publications go. Worse, there are now three less places for aspiring writers of fantasy fiction and non-fiction to be published. A void where the next Robert E. Howard may have made a sale.
It would be easy to lay the blame for the loss of these and other print publications at the feet of declining literacy. While there may some truth behind that, The National Endowment for the Arts reported on January 13 that the number of adult readers actually increased for the first time in over a quarter-century.
I happen to think people are reading more, but increasingly, they’re turning away from print and doing it online. Why pay for a print publication and wait for it to arrive in the mail when you can surf the Web and get free fantasy content on fan sites, blogs, and self-published PDF journals?
Of course, the one major problem with this argument is that many Web sites generate their content from commenting upon and/or sucking the blood from the work of established writers who struggled to break their way into print. What happens when these well-vetted, skillfully edited source materials disappear? Will they all eventually migrate online? I’m not so sure.
Another reason for the demise of print is cost. Print products take more time and more money to produce than electronic media. Blogging software has made it easy for anyone to “publish” (hello, self) at minimal to no cost. But that doesn’t mean the writing produced is particularly good or memorable (ditto, self).
From everything I’ve heard and read, editor Leo Grin worked himself to the bone to get out The Cimmerian. I can attest first-hand that the essays he published required considerable, skillful chisel blows, and in some cases Thor-like hammering. A typical essay went through multiple drafts, was fleshed out and reworked, and strengthened with additional references. They were then professionally laid out, printed, and shipped. This process naturally takes a good deal of time. For a single editor working as a labor of love, it’s nothing short of a sacrifice.
In summary, the loss of these publications should teach us this: If you value something, put your money where your mouth is and purchase it. Or someday they’ll be gone. Print may not be dead, but it’s certainly bleeding.
